The Employment Lifecycle Via A SMCR Lens: Episode 4 – Points On Termination Of Employment – Employment and HR – Canada

The Employment Lifecycle Through A SMCR Lens: Episode 4 – Issues On Termination Of Employment - Employment and HR - Canada

To print this text, all you want is to be registered or login on

Attending to grips with the adjustments which were introduced in as a
results of the Senior Managers and Certification Regime (SMCR) for
all FCA regulated companies just isn’t simple.

In a sequence of six podcasts, we have introduced collectively our
employment and monetary regulation specialists to simplify this space
and clarify clearly what these working inside authorized, danger,
compliance, HR and operations want to consider at every stage of
the employment cycle on the subject of complying with the SMCR.

On this fourth episode, we cowl the problems which may come up on
termination of employment.



Ian Mason: Hiya everybody. I am Ian Mason.
I am a accomplice in Gowling WLG and I head up the monetary
companies and regulatory workforce and this can be a sequence of six podcasts
that we’re bringing to you during which members from Gowling
WLG’s employment and monetary companies regulation groups will
be discussing the problems that come up from an SMCR (Senior Managers
and Certification Regime) perspective at every stage within the
employment cycle.

So, there have been some earlier podcasts and when it comes to what
we’ve got lined up to now we have checked out recruitment, points
throughout employment and taking a better have a look at investigations and
whistleblowing – definitely a sizzling matter for the time being. At present we’re
going to be shifting on to have a look at the top of the cycle what points
may come up on termination in an SMCR context. To debate this
I am joined by Emma Bufton a principal affiliate in our
Employment, Labour and Equalities workforce and Sushil Kuner a principal
affiliate in our Monetary Providers Regulation workforce.

So we’re now trying on the finish of the employment lifecycle,
when an worker is exiting the enterprise and the adjustments introduced in
by the SMCR threw up numerous points and elements for corporations to be
contemplating at this stage, much more so if the worker in query
is a Senior Supervisor and if the explanation for the exit is expounded to a
disciplinary matter involving breaches of Conduct Guidelines. I might
like to come back on to have a look at that in just a little extra element later in
this podcast but when we will begin issues off just a little extra

We have mentioned in an earlier podcast what adjustments will want
to be made to the employment documentation in mild of the SMCR however
I believe it is worthwhile highlighting once more what corporations ought to be
excited about together with to deal adequately with exiting. Emma,
maybe you could possibly begin off by referring to that.

Emma Bufton: Certain, so one of many adjustments I
suppose corporations ought to be making is to replace the listing of abstract
dismissal provisions and the explanation for that is in order that staff
are clear that in the event that they breach any one of many necessities introduced
in by the SCMR that this may occasionally effectively qualify as a abstract dismissal

So for Senior Managers, corporations ought to be trying so as to add the
following to the listing of abstract dismissal offences:

  • any materials negligence or wilful default within the efficiency of
    a Senior Supervisor Operate or prescribed duty;

  • a cloth breach of the Conduct Guidelines;

  • an up to date regulatory reference being supplied by a earlier
    employer which then calls into query that particular person’s
    health and propriety; and

  • any failure to move the agency’s health and propriety

Save for the availability particular to Senior Supervisor Capabilities and
prescribed duties, the opposite offences must also be
listed for licensed individuals and non-executive administrators.

In addition to making adjustments to what would qualify as a abstract
dismissal and I do know Simon’s lined this in an earlier
podcast, employment paperwork must also embrace a contractual
obligation on the Senior Supervisor to supply passable handover
notes and to co-operate with the agency in respect of any
investigations that would relate to that particular person’s health
and propriety.

Ian: So that you talked about there handover notes. Now
this can be a new requirement of the SMCR. Are you able to inform us extra about

Emma: Sure, so the duty as regards to
handover applies to enhanced corporations solely, so not all solo FCA
regulated corporations are going to be lined underneath the SMCR. Broadly
talking what’s required is for affordable steps to be taken to
be certain that an individual holding a Senior Supervisor position has all of the
data and supplies that they may fairly count on to have
with a purpose to do their job successfully.

This ought to be documented formally by corporations and they need to have
insurance policies on their expectations as regards to handovers and
ideally this doc ought to be ready and up to date all through the
interval that that Senior Supervisor is holding a selected Senior
Supervisor Operate. This permits for a extra full and correct
report of the dangers and points related to the Senior Supervisor
Operate the person holds and crucially, it additionally acts as a
contingency plan ought to the Senior Supervisor depart the agency

It might even be prudent for corporations to specify what they count on
that handover to cowl and that is for consistency and for
completeness functions. So some examples that they could need to
take into consideration together with can be:

  • a judgment of the dangers and any issues a Senior Supervisor

  • how a Senior Supervisor discharges their duties and the reporting
    traces inside the space that they’re accountable for;

  • the extent of resourcing and capabilities inside that Senior
    Supervisor’s workforce; and

  • additionally any common interplay or scrutiny that has occurred
    inside the enterprise space.

Now while it’s a requirement underneath the SMCR for enhanced corporations
to have these handover provisions in place, as a matter of excellent
apply, not least for the contingency plan causes I discussed,
it may be a good suggestion for different solo regulated corporations to have a look at
having some type of handover coverage in place too.

Ian: So the handover doc goes to be a
actually necessary a part of the exit course of for Senior Managers and
in fact you have already talked about some key adjustments required to
the employment documentation. On the subject of documentation, there
is clearly going to be a variety of private documentation about
staff that corporations may have on report. Does the SMCR impose any
obligations when it comes to retaining that documentation? I respect
there might be GDPR implications right here too.

Emma: Sure you are proper to lift GDPR and
the Knowledge Safety Act 2018. Agency’s might want to have a lawful
foundation for processing private information and they’ll have to be clear
and clear with staff about how they acquire, retailer,
retain and use their private information however for the needs of
in the present day’s podcast and given the timing constraints I am simply
going to depart it there when it comes to flagging the GDPR factors however
it is definitely one thing that corporations ought to be alive to and
ought to have on their radars.

So trying then on the SMCR necessities on retention, there are
sure data that should be retained for a time period
after the worker has left. So as an illustration, Statements of
Accountability, coaching data and regulatory correspondence and
the period of time that that information should be retained for goes to
rely on that exact information in query.

While we’re on that matter of data, do guarantee that
after the worker leaves that any documentation that mentions that
specific worker is up to date. So as an illustration, if there are any
Accountability Maps that have to be up to date.

Ian: Proper so let’s focus our consideration a
little extra on the regulator. Presumably, if FCA approval is required
to nominate a Senior Supervisor right into a Senior Supervisor Operate they’re
going to need to learn about any departing Senior Supervisor? Is that
proper Sushil and can they need to learn about different departing
staff too? I am pondering right here about any staff who might
have been dismissed for disciplinary causes.

Sushil Kuner
: Sure, effectively the fundamental place for any
non-fault state of affairs involving a Senior Supervisor ceasing to carry out
an FCA designated Senior Administration Operate, is that the agency should
notify the FCA of this inside ten enterprise days of the cessation

Except the Senior Supervisor in query is shifting to a different
Senior Administration Operate inside the similar agency or group, the
notification to the FCA might be by the use of a Kind C which requires a
purpose to be given for the cessation of position. If the Senior Supervisor
is shifting to a different Senior Administration Operate inside the similar
agency or group then the related type might be a Kind E.

Nonetheless there are conditions the place notification by the use of Kind C
must be made earlier. Particularly, notification should be
submitted as quickly as practicable after a agency turns into conscious, or has
data which fairly suggests, that it’s going to submit a
certified Kind C for an FCA permitted Senior Supervisor.

So what’s a Certified Kind C I hear you ask! Properly the Kind C
might be certified if the knowledge it comprises:

  1. pertains to the truth that the agency has dismissed or suspended
    the Senior Supervisor from its employment; or

  2. pertains to the resignation by the Senior Supervisor whereas underneath
    investigation by the agency, the FCA or every other regulatory physique.
    Now I believe Simon Stephen lined this in a bit extra element in
    podcast 4.

The Kind C will even be certified the place it in any other case fairly
means that it might have an effect on the FCA’s evaluation of the Senior
Supervisor’s propriety or embrace in regards to the Senior Supervisor underneath
statutory provisions regarding grounds for withdrawal of approval
and disciplinary motion.

Virtually, what this implies is that the place any of these
circumstances exist, corporations could also be required to submit a professional
Kind C prematurely of the particular cessation date.

Corporations ought to word that they’ve an obligation to provide the FCA
with full and correct data required by Kind C,
no matter any settlement settled by the Advisory, Conciliation
and Arbitration Service or every other settlement or settlement
settlement entered into by the agency and the worker. A agency ought to
not enter into any such preparations that would battle with its
obligations underneath the SMCR.

Ian: Thanks Sushil. What about these staff
who’re dismissed for breaches of the Conduct Guidelines?

Sushil: Properly if an worker has been dismissed
for breaches of the FCA’s Conduct Guidelines, which I spoke about in
element in podcast 2, except the breach or particular person’s
misconduct was critical sufficient to warrant a notification to the FCA
underneath Principal 11, then the small print round this termination will
solely have to be included within the agency’s annual notification of
breaches of conduct guidelines by workers.

Though conduct guidelines breaches might be critical, you may think about
conditions the place they don’t seem to be so critical to warrant a direct
notification to the FCA underneath Precept 11, however do nonetheless
lead to termination of employment. For instance, frequent errors
on the a part of claims or arrears handlers who could also be on private
improvement plans, which don’t result in hurt because of High quality
Assurance measures in place. Nonetheless, these competency causes will
go to the person’s Health and Propriety and will have to be
included in any regulatory reference.

Ian: Little doubt dismissals for a conduct associated
purpose are going to have an effect on the worker’s regulatory
reference and I can see that this might turn out to be fairly contentious.
Emma do you agree?

Emma: I definitely do, sure. So the onus is on
the agency finishing the reference to supply as full an image
of the worker’s conduct report as potential and that is all
a part of shifting duty for verifying people’
health and propriety from the regulator to corporations and the report
should embrace particulars of any disciplinary motion which incorporates the
issuing of a proper warning, suspension or dismissal or the
discount/restoration of such an individual’s remuneration.

Now difficulties usually come up if the worker sees the writing on
the wall and chooses to depart earlier than or half approach via a
disciplinary investigation. What does that then imply for the
regulatory reference? Properly this goes again to one of many most important
causes for the SMCR and introducing regulatory reference being to
forestall dangerous apples from rolling. So corporations cannot wiggle out of
finishing investigations simply because an worker has left. The
course of will have to be finalised so far as potential with the
worker given the chance to remark and for the result to be
recorded within the reference too, once more with the worker having had
the chance to remark.

In actuality, what this implies is that allegations of misconduct
are more likely to be bitterly fought by staff as an adversarial
regulatory reference may have profession ending penalties.

Remember additionally, and I do know we talked about this in our first
podcast, that references have to be up to date if corporations uncover any
wrongdoing after the worker has left. It is price mentioning
as effectively, which builds on the feedback Sushil made earlier about
Kind Cs, that the principles are clear that corporations can’t agree
settlement agreements or COT3s with staff limiting what would
in any other case be stated in a regulatory reference and such an association
like that will be void.

Ian: effectively thanks each very a lot. That is
been very attention-grabbing and informative however I believe that is all
we have got time for on this podcast however do preserve a glance out for
our additional podcasts on this sequence. Thanks in your consideration
and have a superb day.

Missed the earlier episodes? Take heed to
‘The employment lifecycle via a SMCR lens: episode
1’, during which we begin initially of the employment
cycle, exploring all issues recruitment and
The employment lifecycle via a SMCR lens: episode 2 – points
arising throughout employment the place we have a look at points arising
throughout employment and
The employment lifecycle via a SMCR lens: episode 3 -
whistleblowing the place we talk about the topical space of

Learn the unique article on

The content material of this text is meant to supply a normal
information to the subject material. Specialist recommendation ought to be sought
about your particular circumstances.

Supply hyperlink

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.