Soccer might be taught from hockey’s video umpire system

Soccer could learn from hockey's video umpire system

LAUSANNE, Switzerland: Hockey could get pleasure from solely a fraction of soccer’s wealth and glamour but the game’s governing physique believes it might educate its greater cousin a couple of issues about the usage of know-how.

Like soccer, hockey makes use of video replays in main competitions to make key selections. Whereas it isn’t proof against controversies over the choices themselves, hockey officers consider its video system is much less intrusive and extra clear than soccer’s.

In soccer, a video assistant checks key selections and suggests a VAR evaluate if it seems the pitch referee has acquired it incorrect. But many followers complain that targets are disallowed for trivial causes, typically after gamers and stadium announcers have celebrated.

Hockey makes use of the problem system the place a crew can ask for a evaluate in the event that they consider a call is incorrect. If the video umpire agrees, they hold their proper to a problem; if not, they lose it for the remainder of the sport.

“In impact, it implies that within the first half, no one asks for the video umpire. You do not joke round as a result of you understand in case you are incorrect, you penalise the crew for the remainder of the sport,” mentioned Thierry Weil, chief govt of the Worldwide Hockey Federation (FiH).

Replays of the incident are proven to the group and dialog between umpiring officers is broadcast to the general public – which doesn’t occur in soccer.

“Generally soccer ought to hearken to what different sports activities do, and never solely hockey,” Weil, a former FIFA advertising director, advised a small group of reporters.

Weil was additionally happy with the way in which the gamers had been monitored throughout prime video games.

“Each single participant on the sector of play is monitored so the coach can take gamers off and convey them on primarily based on their bodily situation,” he mentioned.


Weil mentioned innovation was necessary in hockey, which is without doubt one of the oldest Olympic sports activities however is now wanting over its shoulder with newer sports activities clamouring to be allowed into the Video games.

“You have got sports activities knocking on the door that are being thought-about as cool sports activities and our sport will not be so cool,” he mentioned. “So you need to be on prime of your sport and never taking issues with no consideration.”

One concept he want to implement is to put a lightweight contained in the ball which makes it glow and extinguishes when time is up. “It’s the type of factor we have to deliver to the game,” he mentioned.

Weil mentioned the FiH would additionally finish the observe of watering the unreal pitches used for hockey as an environmental measure by 2024, although he admitted that “some folks say this can kill hockey”.

“You play a World Cup in India and put tonnes of water on the sector of play while subsequent door they do not have water to drink, this isn’t one thing that may proceed,” he mentioned.

Weil additionally wished extra moveable pitches within the Professional League – a worldwide league that includes 9 groups in each the boys’s and ladies’s competitions – such because the one deployed on the Twickenham Stoop rugby stadium for England’s residence matches final season.

He mentioned that was preferable to the non permanent stadiums which needed to be constructed for many video games.

“If we will use present infrastructure like we did in England, that’s extraordinarily helpful,” he mentioned. “Momentary infrastructure includes a number of work and cash, and you need to construct the bathrooms for that… Once you hear what we now have spent on moveable bathrooms, it is nonsense.”

(Writing by Brian Homewood; Modifying by Toby Davis)

Supply hyperlink

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.